I am home this week, working on my doctoral dissertation proposal, and need references to cite for a "personal rate of return."
And so, like any good researcher, I began with a "Google search," and found the "Finance guy's" blog, which has a post on this subject. He references an earlier one, where he advocates using the Original Dietz, across the full year, rather than the XIRR. While it's true that it can provide roughly the same result, the industry has pretty much abandoned this mid-point method. Okay, if your readers are truly unsophisticated investors, with limited math skills, perhaps this is okay, but I would couch such a formula with an explanation that its accuracy is not very good.
In the more recent post he has the following:
The personal rate of return you get from a financial service provider like Fidelity or Schwab is usually a Time Weighted Rate of Return. If you want a Dollar Weighted Rate of Return, you will have to do it yourself.
A "time-weighted rate of return" as a "personal" rate of return? What is personal about a time-weighted return? Ten people are invested in the same fund, but contribute different amounts during the year. What will their "personal rate of return" be under time-weighting? The same as the fund's performance, because by definition, we've eliminated the impact of the cash flows.
He cites another website, dailyVest, whose post on this subject states
Time-weighted rates of return can be calculated on a daily basis (one method
known as Daily Valuation) or on a slightly less
accurate monthly basis (known as Modified Dietz) where
inflows/outflows are averaged for the month. This time-weighted methodology used
for calculation of personal rate of return provides a truer measurement of how
investments are performing.
No, no, no! A "personal rate of return" has to be "personal," does it not? And how do we get this? By taking the flows into consideration.
Perhaps we have a bit of Clinton-like speech here (as in, "it depends on what you mean by the word, is"), at least in dailyVest's case, because one might ask what "This" means, in "This time-weighted methodology." If they're referring to Modified Dietz, then they get partial credit. However, by linking the intraperiod Modified Dietz-derived returns, we achieve an approximation to a time-weighted return, which is not a money-weighted method.
The site "All Financial Matters" gets it right, because this author cites the XIRR as the formula to use. In his post he provides an example of an investor putting money into the Vanguard S&P 500 Index Fund (VFNIX), and states:
Some simple math will tell us that VFNIX returned 6.8% (not including dividends) from 1/31 – 12/31 ((111.64 – 104.54) ÷ 104.54). However, the real question is: how did the portfolio perform for you? Or, what was your personal rate of return?
Given that the investor made contributions during the year, he correctly references the XIRR (i.e., a money-weighted method) to obtain the personal rate of return.
Speaking of Vanguard, they have a brief video that describes the personal rate of return.
Time-weighting offers nothing personal to the investor.We need a money-weighted formula for that, be it (an unlinked) Modified Dietz, as a proxy for the true, exact, money-weighted return, or the internal rate of return. If there are no flows, then the TWRR equals the MWRR.
There is nothing "personal" about time-weighted methods. If you want a "personal rate of return," use an MWRR formula.
Thursday, August 16, 2012
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
The use and misues of statistics, part II
It was just yesterday that I commented on a WSJ article that spoke of the potential misuse of statistics. And today, in this very paper, on the top of page B1 we read the headline "BMW's 'Demo' Sales Boost Results."
The article speaks of how BMW reported a sale of "21,297 of its flagship-brand cars in the U.S. in July," and these "numbers are not as straightforward as they appear," because "Hundreds of BMWs counted as sold in July remain in showroom inventories and are still advertised for sale as new cars."
It seems that BMW offered their dealers an incentive to acquire cars on July 31 and receive a $7,000 discount, provided they be reported as "sold."
Where does it end?
But our industry sees this sort of thing too, does it not? The incentive to present information in just the right light. This is why standards, such as GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) and UAPS (Universal Advisor Performance Standards) are critically important. While flexibility is offered, their remain fundamental rules which must be adhered to.
The article speaks of how BMW reported a sale of "21,297 of its flagship-brand cars in the U.S. in July," and these "numbers are not as straightforward as they appear," because "Hundreds of BMWs counted as sold in July remain in showroom inventories and are still advertised for sale as new cars."
It seems that BMW offered their dealers an incentive to acquire cars on July 31 and receive a $7,000 discount, provided they be reported as "sold."
Where does it end?
But our industry sees this sort of thing too, does it not? The incentive to present information in just the right light. This is why standards, such as GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) and UAPS (Universal Advisor Performance Standards) are critically important. While flexibility is offered, their remain fundamental rules which must be adhered to.
Tuesday, August 14, 2012
The use and misuse of statistics
In today's WSJ, William McGurn has an article on John James Cowperthwaite ("Go for Bust, Mr. Romney"), which provides some background into Hong Kong's phenomenal success (he cites, for example, the rise in per capita income relative to Great Britain: it was 28% of GB's in 1960, and 137% in 1996). He credits Sir John with much of their success.
He also quotes Cowperthwaite, who "forbade officials from keeping numbers even for such things as gross domestic product":
Perhaps Sir John was also a fan of Mark Twain, who famously said that there were three types of lies:
And so, should we all adopt Sir John's rule of not showing statistics? There have been suggestions that this would be appropriate. For example, not many years back, as I recall, a UK regulator questioned the appropriateness of reporting returns, if "past performance is no indication of future results."
The U.S. witnessed the appearance of misleading performance presentations in the mid 1980s, when for the first time we saw institutional asset managers advertise their past performance. Many of us believe this served as a catalyst for the FAF (Financial Analysts Federation) Performance Presentation Standards, which led to the AIMR-PPS(R), and then to GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards).
And this, of course, is the answer to those who question the use of statistics: rules. GIPS applies to much of the investment market, and new UAPS (Universal Advisor Performance Standards) will apply to other segments. Those who receive statistics should ensure that the provider adheres to the appropriate rules. Of course, their claim of compliance (and sadly, even sometimes when they've been verified) is no guarantee, as a few have still managed to get away with fraud. But, this is at least a start.
And so, with all due respect to Sir John and Mark Twain, statistics have value and should be reported. The recipient just needs to ensure they understand what's being shown and ideally that it conforms to industry standards of practice.
He also quotes Cowperthwaite, who "forbade officials from keeping numbers even for such things as gross domestic product":
"If I let them keep statistics...
they can only misuse them."
Perhaps Sir John was also a fan of Mark Twain, who famously said that there were three types of lies:
- lies,
- damned lies, and
- statistics.
And so, should we all adopt Sir John's rule of not showing statistics? There have been suggestions that this would be appropriate. For example, not many years back, as I recall, a UK regulator questioned the appropriateness of reporting returns, if "past performance is no indication of future results."
The U.S. witnessed the appearance of misleading performance presentations in the mid 1980s, when for the first time we saw institutional asset managers advertise their past performance. Many of us believe this served as a catalyst for the FAF (Financial Analysts Federation) Performance Presentation Standards, which led to the AIMR-PPS(R), and then to GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards).
And this, of course, is the answer to those who question the use of statistics: rules. GIPS applies to much of the investment market, and new UAPS (Universal Advisor Performance Standards) will apply to other segments. Those who receive statistics should ensure that the provider adheres to the appropriate rules. Of course, their claim of compliance (and sadly, even sometimes when they've been verified) is no guarantee, as a few have still managed to get away with fraud. But, this is at least a start.
And so, with all due respect to Sir John and Mark Twain, statistics have value and should be reported. The recipient just needs to ensure they understand what's being shown and ideally that it conforms to industry standards of practice.
Thursday, August 9, 2012
Another victory for money-weighting!
The United States Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) recently introduced new provisions that call for the reporting of money-weighting rates of return, using the internal rate of return (IRR).
The new provision, Statement No. 67 of the Governmental Accounting Standards Board, titled Financial Reporting for Pension Plans, includes the following details.
On page 12, paragraph 30.b.(4) you'll find
And then on page 17:
The document also includes a glossary, with the following definition:
I had been speaking with someone from GASB a few months back, answering his questions as well as offering my views on money-weighting. Obviously, I'm thrilled that they opted to go with this measure, as opposed to time-weighting, which was their original plan.
If you're involved with or support a government pension fund, you'll want to ensure you adhere to these new rules. And, if you're not a government fund, it's still worthwhile to become familiar with them, because money-weighting is catching on!
Note: The Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) is the independent organization that establishes and improves standards of accounting and financial reporting for U.S. state and local governments. Established in 1984 by agreement of the Financial Accounting Foundation (FAF) and 10 national associations of state and local government officials, the GASB is recognized by governments, the accounting industry, and the capital markets as the official source of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) for state and local governments.
The new provision, Statement No. 67 of the Governmental Accounting Standards Board, titled Financial Reporting for Pension Plans, includes the following details.
On page 12, paragraph 30.b.(4) you'll find
And then on page 17:
The document also includes a glossary, with the following definition:
I had been speaking with someone from GASB a few months back, answering his questions as well as offering my views on money-weighting. Obviously, I'm thrilled that they opted to go with this measure, as opposed to time-weighting, which was their original plan.
If you're involved with or support a government pension fund, you'll want to ensure you adhere to these new rules. And, if you're not a government fund, it's still worthwhile to become familiar with them, because money-weighting is catching on!
Note: The Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) is the independent organization that establishes and improves standards of accounting and financial reporting for U.S. state and local governments. Established in 1984 by agreement of the Financial Accounting Foundation (FAF) and 10 national associations of state and local government officials, the GASB is recognized by governments, the accounting industry, and the capital markets as the official source of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) for state and local governments.
Wednesday, August 8, 2012
Internet Tips & Tricks
This month's Spaulding Group webinar will be on Monday, August 27, from 11:00 AM to 12:30 PM EST, and it will be a bit different. Titled Internet Tips & Tricks, it will provide you with some interesting insights into better ways to improve your Internet experience!
The webinar instructor is Vasant Bhat, PhD. I had Professor Bhat in one of my doctoral classes at Pace University, and he demonstrated a tremendous familiarity with neat ways to use the web. He graciously accepted our invitation to host this program, and we're confident you'll enjoy it.
He will explain better ways to explore the Internet, including how to find important data and information critical to you and your firm. You will be introduced to cool tips and tricks that can significantly enhance your web experience and gain insights into ways to better utilize the tremendous resources of the Internet.
Space is limited, so reserve your Webinar seat today!
Note: the webinar is free for Performance Measurement Forum members and TSG verification clients. All others will pay a nominal site fee, meaning you can have as many folks on the call as you would like.
The webinar instructor is Vasant Bhat, PhD. I had Professor Bhat in one of my doctoral classes at Pace University, and he demonstrated a tremendous familiarity with neat ways to use the web. He graciously accepted our invitation to host this program, and we're confident you'll enjoy it.
He will explain better ways to explore the Internet, including how to find important data and information critical to you and your firm. You will be introduced to cool tips and tricks that can significantly enhance your web experience and gain insights into ways to better utilize the tremendous resources of the Internet.
Space is limited, so reserve your Webinar seat today!
Note: the webinar is free for Performance Measurement Forum members and TSG verification clients. All others will pay a nominal site fee, meaning you can have as many folks on the call as you would like.
Tuesday, August 7, 2012
GIPS Survey 2012
The Spaulding Group has announced that it is conducting a survey on the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS(R)). This marks the eighth time we've conducted a survey on the presentation standards, starting with the AIMR-PPS in 1993. This makes our firm the leader in gathering information on these vitally important standards.
The survey's length has been trimmed, to (a) make it quicker to go through (it should take you only five minutes or so to complete), (b) allows us to focus on the most important issues, and (c) should result in even more participants!
And speaking of participants, all will receive a complimentary copy of the results! So please join in today!
Oh, and before I forget, I want to acknowledge the firms who are sponsoring this research effort:
The survey's length has been trimmed, to (a) make it quicker to go through (it should take you only five minutes or so to complete), (b) allows us to focus on the most important issues, and (c) should result in even more participants!
And speaking of participants, all will receive a complimentary copy of the results! So please join in today!
Oh, and before I forget, I want to acknowledge the firms who are sponsoring this research effort:
Monday, August 6, 2012
Should this be a required UAPS or GIPS disclosure?
I try to exercise every morning, and when I do, I often watch the news.
This morning there was an advertisement from CancerCenter.com, that included the following disclaimer:
It occurred to me that such a statement might be an appropriate inclusion in any presentation of past performance results, be they in compliance with the Universal Advisor Performance Standards (UAPS), the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS(R)), or simply reporting that complies with no standard to a prospective client.
It's a fact, is it not? There are no "typical" cases. We have averages, but often even the averages don't represent any account in particular, but rather represent the blending of accounts.
What do you think? Should this be a required statement? Would it add to the presentation or better serve the prospect?
This morning there was an advertisement from CancerCenter.com, that included the following disclaimer:
No case is typical.
You should not expect to experience these results.
It occurred to me that such a statement might be an appropriate inclusion in any presentation of past performance results, be they in compliance with the Universal Advisor Performance Standards (UAPS), the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS(R)), or simply reporting that complies with no standard to a prospective client.
It's a fact, is it not? There are no "typical" cases. We have averages, but often even the averages don't represent any account in particular, but rather represent the blending of accounts.
What do you think? Should this be a required statement? Would it add to the presentation or better serve the prospect?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



.png)
.png)

.png)


