Showing posts with label rates of return. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rates of return. Show all posts

Friday, June 22, 2012

Alternative Investments ... just scratching the surface

At this week's European Performance Measurement Forum meeting, we touched on the subject of alternative investments. We hear this term bandied about quite a bit; so much so, that it often causes one to grimace when they hear it, because of the fear it can invoke.

While this category can include credit default swaps, as well as other varieties of swaps and swaptions; futures, forwards, and options; along with commodities and fairly esoteric investments, such as guitars, watches, and artwork; it also is where we house [pardon the pun] real estate and private equity.

In the case of real estate and private equity, while we may not know all the answers, many of the rules are fairly well agreed upon. The GIPS(R) standards (Global Investment Performance Standards) after all includes rules specifically for these asset classes.

But there is a broad, make that very broad, collection of instruments for which the rules are less clear. And when we speak about rules, we must consider:
  • Valuing the assets
  • Deriving returns on the assets
  • Measuring risk of the assets
  • Determining how to handle them as part of our attribution
  • and no doubt a lot more.
This is a topic that we will not attempt to address quickly, as much time is needed for it. Hopefully, we will be able to provide guidance on much of what is faced in the industry today. And so, stay tuned! In the mean time, if you have ideas or questions, please pass them along!

Friday, February 24, 2012

Topology makes it way into performance and risk

Yesterday, The Spaulding Group held a luncheon in NYC, where Jed Schneider, CIPM, FRM reviewed some of the findings from our recent Performance Attribution survey. As with all of these research projects, some very interesting insights can be drawn. And since this is the fourth time we've surveyed asset managers on this topic, we can compare results from one period to another, to identify trends, changes, etc. Our cosponsors for this survey were:
As with all of our surveys, we invited our cosponsors to come to the luncheon and make brief presentations, and four did. One, Steve Shefras from BiSam, mentioned how it is often said that risk and return are two sides of the same coin. He went on to say that he believes they're on the same side. I immediately thought of a totally different anaology: a Möbious strip!

You may be familiar with them. They come from the mathematical field topology, that deals with "mapping." A Möbious strip is a one-sided object. You can build your own by taking a long strip of paper, twisting it, and then connecting the ends. If you traverse either "side," you'll cover both "sides,"  meaning there is only one side.

And so, rather than saying that risk and return are on the same side of a coin (which encourages one to ask, "what's on the other side?"), we could say that they're both on a Möbious strip, and therefore on the same (and only) side.

Monday, May 9, 2011

How to explain positive returns when losses occur

Today's animation discusses the fairly common situation, where a portfolio loses money but has a positive return.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Treatment of reinvestment of income in returns

A colleague sent us a note recently inquiring about the proper treatment of accounts that have dividends reinvested; that is, how the flows are to be handled from a return perspective. The essential question is "should the money flowing into the account, to purchase additional shares, be treated as a cash flow?" And the answer is a conditional one:
  • If you treated the dividend that flowed out of the account as a cash flow, then yes
  • If you didn't treat the divided that flowed out as a cash flow, then no.
We essentially want our flows to cancel each other out, as the dividend's impact should be kept within the account, and the manager should benefit from it. We cannot treat only the money coming in as a flow because then the manager wouldn't get credit for creating it.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Two (or more) sets of books

I conducted a GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) verification for a client on Monday and was asked if it made sense to calculate returns in multiple ways. That is, if they know that the client's custodian or consultant calculates returns using a different method than prescribed by GIPS, would it be prudent to maintain a separate return stream which they could turn to in the event they need to reconcile?

I was intrigued by this question as it hadn't previously been posed, and I am unaware of anyone who does this.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with maintaining multiple sets of returns. But, I recommended that they don't do this as a matter of standard practice, but rather only when approached to justify their return or reconcile to one (or both) the other parties. Why do all this work when you don't know if it will be needed? Wait and then do the appropriate calculations and analysis.

There are many reasons for potential differences in returns, and the return formula is just one. Many asset managers are often charged with doing this sort of thing and perhaps if they know that a particular client religiously asks them to prove out their numbers, then in that case perhaps doing it on an ongoing basis makes sense, but otherwise, I'd do it ad hoc.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

How come the math doesn't work out?

We recently received an inquiry from a client regarding netting of advisory fees:

If an annual fee schedule is 60bps after you link the returns for 1 year it looks like returns were reduced by 88bps. I know is because we are linking and not adding or subtracting but for some reason is not making any sense to others.

GOF Return for 1 year ending 01/31/2010= 67.52%
NOF return for 1 year ending 01/31/2010= 66.64%
Annual fee schedule: 60bps


This doesn't make sense, right? And so, let's walk through the math. First, I want to find the monthly equivalent of the annual GOF return: I simply add one to the annual return (1.6752) and raise it to the 1/12 power, and then subtract one. My answer: 4.39% (there are some extra decimal places which you'll no doubt retain in your spreadsheet). I geometrically link these and tie to the 67.52% annual return as provided.

Next, I divide the annual fee (0.60%) by 12 (0.05%) and enter this for each month; I geometrically link these and the result is my 60 bps return. (Actually, there are some trailing decimal places: 6016527...). It is important to point out that our arithmetically derived monthly return won't geometrically link to the starting annual return; they're only this close when the numbers are quite small, as in this case. We'll discuss this further.

For each month, I derive the net-of-fee return by simply subtracting the 5 bp fee from the monthly gross-of-fee return: 4.34 percent. I then geometrically link these and obtain an annual return of 66.56%; note that this doesn't match the NOF return our client has, but this can be for a variety of reasons, one being that their returns varied from month to month, while I kept them equal for simplicity purposes. Our results:

(NOTE: click on the above figure to see the entire spreadsheet)

We expect that our GOF minus NOF annual returns should equal our annual fee of 0.60%; however, it doesn't! It's 0.96%. How come?

It has to do with compounding. Think of this problem as if we were dealing with excess returns, where our fee is the benchmark and the NOF return represents our excess return. We know, from numerous articles, that arithmetically derived excess returns don't link: this is why we have such tools as those developed by Menchero, Carino, and Frongello for multi-period attribution.

Our monthly net-of-fee returns will not geometrically link at the same rate as our gross-of-fee returns, because there's a size difference: compounding builds upon prior periods, and the larger the prior period's value, the greater the rate of compounding. I hope this explanation makes sense. The results are correct; they just don't tie out as we'd like them to or believe they should.

Thursday, February 11, 2010

To how many decimal places?

I'm looking at a client report (fortunately not one that they would give to a client) that shows, for example, the return 41.29959483 percent. Such precision! To eight decimal places! I'm impressed. Well, actually I'm not.

Actually, this is a waste of ink, yes? One can't confuse precision with accuracy. What possible value would anyone have in a number to this level of detail? As if it's actually right? The report is produced from a software system: why would a vendor have this information default to such a value? Seems odd to me.

I was on a flight recently and the pilot announced that the flight would last 2 hours, 52 minutes, and 40 seconds. Actually, he said it would last "approximately" that long. Approximately? To paraphrase Dorothy from Jerry Maguire, you had me at 2 hours, 52 minutes; and, you could have rounded to 50 minutes (I won't be running my stopwatch to validate your accuracy). You could have probably just said "approximately three hours." But no doubt there are some folks that like to hear flight times to such precision and perhaps even believe they're accurate.

Even returns with three decimal places seem a bit ridiculous, except where excess returns (and returns in general) are so small that we need this additional precision or show zeroes.

Don't confuse precision with accuracy: they're two different things. We should strive for accuracy but recognize that even that isn't always as achievable as we'd like. There's a lot of noise out there that makes 8-decimal place returns a joke. 

Monday, January 11, 2010

Calculating returns with little data (revisited)


Last Friday I posed a question about how one would derive returns when they had limited data: month-end holdings and period transactions. A couple folks basically explained that this CAN be done. Here's what you do:
  • Take your holdings file and preceding transactions and
  • back into the holdings for any prior period.
By transactions, we're assuming you have buys, sells, income, and corporate actions. With this information, you can get anywhere.

Really simple example: your holdings file for 12/31/09 shows you have 100 shares of IBM and 200 shares of Ford, plus $500 in cash. You'd like to know what you looked like on 11/30/09. Your 11/30/09 - 12/31/09 transactions list:
  • 12/15/09: sale of 1,000 shares of Citicorp for $5,000
  • 12/17/09: purchase 200 shares of Ford for $3,000
  • 12/23/09: withdrawal of $1,500
What we do is start with our current position and reverse all the entries:
  • 12/23/09: withdrawal of $1,500 becomes a contribution of $1,500 (our $500 becomes $2,000)
  • 12/17/09: purchase of 200 shares of Ford for $3,000 becomes a sale of 200 shares (our 200 shares go to zero and we add $3000 to cash)
  • 12/15/09: sale of 1,000 Citi becomes a purchase of 1,000 shares (we pick up 1,000 shares and reduce our cash by $5,000)
Meaning, that on 11/30/09 we held:
  • 1,000 shares of Citi
  • 100 shares of IBM
  • zero cash.
This may help:

As you can see, I took our starting position and simply reversed all the entries. Granted, this was a very simple example, but you at least see how it works. You would need to get pricing for 11/30/09.

By the way, if you plan to do this manually, depending on how many periods you need to create and how many positions and transactions, you could be doing it a while.

What's the lesson here? Well, first, it means you do not have to store every day's position! You can store monthly positions and always back into any specific day. In the world of IT (information technology), there's always the issue about processing time versus space. Granted, disc storage has gotten a lot cheaper, but if you don't need to store dailies, why bother? Second, if you have to reconstruct records and have minimal information, you may still be able to accomplish it.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Calculating returns with little data


I'm spending most of this week on an assignment for a client who is engaged in a lawsuit; well, actually I'm doing the work for the client's attorney. I'm charged with calculating returns for the stocks in the portfolio, and was given only year-end statements that include the year-end positions, along with transactions, income, and disbursements for the year. The first year only has that year's ending position. The exercise spans six years. How does one do this?

I am calculating both time- and money-weighted returns. I'll therefore need monthly returns for the time-weighting. So, how would you do it?

Again, all you have are:
  • year-end positions
  • transactions for the year
  • income for the year
  • disbursements for the year.
I'll let you ponder this awhile before stating how I did it.

BTW, I think this would be a good exercise for the CIPM program!