Thursday, May 31, 2012

10 Steps to GIPS Compliance

The Spaulding Group's latest book, The Spaulding Group's Guide to the Performance Presentation Standards (Spaulding, Simpson & Schneider) includes 10 steps for firms to achieve compliance with GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards). I thought I'd share them with you:
  1. Read the book (the book being the Standards themselves, but our new book can't hurt, either!)
  2. Assign responsibilities
  3. Define the firm
  4. Define the composites
  5. Develop policies & procedures
  6. Assign accounts to composites
  7. Get your records in order
  8. Put it all together
  9. Prepare marketing materials / disclosures
  10. Get checked out (both internally as well as with the help of an independent verifier (i.e., get a verification done!).
That's it! Can it be any simpler?  J

Of course, it's not simple, and for many firms, some steps may require a great deal of effort. We typically begin our verification assignments with a "pre-verification," which includes a "mini" GIPS class, to help orient the firm. We also provide them with our new "GIPS Orientation Kit™." For most firms, compliance is worth the investment!

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Can you show two benchmarks in your GIPS presentation?

When you hear the same question multiple times in a short period, chances are it's a fairly common one, so I'll respond.

The question: Can a GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) compliant firm show two (or more) benchmarks in a GIPS presentation?

The answer: Yes! However, if you're going to do this you need to identify which is the "primary" benchmark.

Some firms like to show the components of a blended benchmark, alongside the blend: that's fine! Others like to show something like the consumer price index; that's fine, too.

Just make sure you identify the primary; arguably the others appear for "reference" purposes.

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

What to attribute events to can be a challenge

At last week's North America Performance Measurement, Attribution & Risk (PMAR) conference, I provided an update on research I'm doing on holdings vs. transaction based attribution. Many investment professionals are aware that the holdings based approach typically results in residuals (i.e., unexplained differences between the sum of the attribution effects and the excess return). What isn't widely known is the mis-assignment of attribution effects, which can result in erroneous and misleading reports.

Yesterday we were hosting our immediate family for a picnic/pool party. As I walked outside to take bags of ice to our cooler, I tripped and fell. My wife responded by trying to come to my aid, only to stumble herself. And while I suffered no injury at all, she had a severe sprain. The cause of her injury? My falling, of course, for she wouldn't have fallen had I not done so myself.

Knowing where the blame or credit goes is important. What we don't need are reports that provide the wrong assessments.

Monday, May 28, 2012

Happy Memorial Day

Kind of odd, I think, to wish someone a "Happy Memorial Day," since the day's real purpose is to honor those American military men and women who "paid the ultimate sacrifice," by dying for their country in battle, to protect our freedom. I also realize that around most of the world today, the stock markets are open; but here in the U.S., it's a national holiday, so most of us have off (and our markets are closed).

Memorial Day serves as the "official start of summer," although summer doesn't technically begin for another three weeks. But many (like us) are having picnics and barbecues. Too few don't pause to reflect on what this day is all about.

We wish another a "Happy Memorial Day" in the hopes that it's an enjoyable one for them. But perhaps also we might pause, even for a brief moment, to reflect, to pray, to contemplate the sacrifices of others on our behalf.

As for today's picture, I took it from my friend Herb Chain's Facebook post.

Friday, May 25, 2012

UAPS vs. GIPS

Earlier this week we announced a new standard which The Spaulding Group and BrightScope are working on: the Universal Advisor Performance Standards or UAPS. At this week's North America Performance Measurement, Attribution & Risk (PMAR) conference in Philadelphia, a few folks inquired into how these standards related to GIPS(R).

I guess one might expect that this initiative would engender some confusion, since the Global Investment Performance Standards have been around for almost 13 years, and have gained a tremendous amount of well deserved support and attention. The distinction between GIPS and the UAPS is, I believe, fairly clear.

GIPS is for asset management who manage client money and who wish to present their past performance to prospective clients. We are dealing with legally discretionary assets (i.e., assets where the client has given the manager the right to trade on their behalf) that further meet the firm's "GIPS discretionary" rules (that is, where the client has not imposed a restriction or requirement that causes the resulting portfolio not to be representative of the manager's strategy).

UAPS is intended for the retail / high net worth / wealth management arenas, where we often find individual financial planners and advisors who may provide their non-discretionary clients with advice and recommendations or have independent responsibility to manage their discretionary clients' assets.

When a firm has thousands of financial planners, scattered throughout the country, each independently managing client assets, to attempt to bring that firm into compliance with GIPS is a virtual impossibility. And so, these investment professionals want some standard they can use to ensure their reporting is appropriate, and which they can claim compliance with.

Let me make my next point very clear: UAPS does not compete with GIPS. It does not intend to serve the same market. Using a Venn diagram, we have the following:

For several years I have witnessed the confusion that exists within, for example, the U.S. brokerage community, where registered reps, financial planners, and investment advisors frequently ask their firm "are we GIPS compliant?" or "are our reports GIPS compliant?" or "are our returns GIPS compliant?" Clearly, GIPS has a far reaching presence. Unfortunately, these are the wrong questions, because these firms cannot easily achieve GIPS compliance. But with only one standard to use, it is not surprising that this occurs.

Whenever I suggested that a new standard, designed specifically for this market, was needed, the response has been over-whelmingly positive. And although we have wanted to develop a standard for this market, for a variety of reasons we couldn't make progress. Until now.

Last Fall we learned about the fellows at BrightScope, and reached out to them to discuss our idea of a standard, and they were very enthusiastic and offered to help. And so, we began the journey to develop such a standard. We are pleased and enthused by the progress we've made in a fairly short time, and are now ready to move to the next step of vetting and enhancing the document with a group of investment and performance professionals.

If you have any questions about the standards, please reach out. Contact information is at our website, where you can also obtain a copy of our draft white paper.

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

ANNOUNCEMENT! New Performance Standard Proposed

BrightScope and The Spaulding Group, Inc. Release White Paper That Proposes a Universal Performance Standard for Financial Advisors

The Adoption of Universal Advisor Performance Standards Will Broaden the Base of Advisors Who Can Report Performance to Both Clients and Prospects

Somerset, NJ - May 22, 2012
Contact:
Jaime Puerschner
PR for The Spaulding Group
732-873-5700

Katie Carlson
Atomic PR for BrightScope
415-593-1400

BrightScope, a leading provider of independent financial information and investment research, and The Spaulding Group, a global leader in investment performance measurement products and services, today jointly announced the release of a new white paper, "Universal Advisory Performance Standards," highlighting the need for an industry consensus performance standard for financial advisors. The free white paper can be downloaded at www.uapstandards.org.

Today’s technology allows consumers to quickly and easily search for and compare mutual funds, 401k plans, mortgages, and many other types of financial products online, but when it comes to financial advisors there is not an efficient way to select one based on performance.
"Over time, we envision that every financial advisor will want and need to disclose the performance of their investment selections on behalf of clients," said Mike Alfred, the CEO and co-founder of BrightScope. "As the leading performance measurement firm in the money management industry, The Spaulding Group’s expertise is perfectly complimentary to BrightScope’s vision, and together we’re confident we can unify the industry around this new standard."

Currently many advisors and broker-dealers do not calculate and do not disclose performance to the general public, making it difficult for prospects to select the right advisor and challenging for the best advisors to grow their practice. As a result, the act of selecting an advisor has been limited to personal recommendations, and what little information consumers can find on the SEC and FINRA websites.

"BrightScope Advisor Pages has done a good job to bring transparency into the marketplace, however since there is no clear guidance or industry standard, many advisors refrain from reporting performance out of fear they might run afoul of SEC and FINRA advertising regulations," said David Spaulding, President of The Spaulding Group, Inc."When there is a single standard created specifically for the money management industry, individuals will understandably assume that it applies to them, when it may not. As a result, there can be confusion as well as the use of something that is less than appropriate. By introducing a new standard, specifically designed for financial advisors, we should see increased reporting; it will also allow investors to make a more informed decision on which professional is best qualified to serve them."

To further support universal standards, BrightScope and The Spaulding Group have founded the Committee for a Universal Advisor Performance Standard. Inaugural advisors to the committee include John Rekenthaler, Vice President of Research at Morningstar; Ric Edelman, Chairman and CEO of Edelman Financial Services LLC; James Edmonds, Executive Director at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney; Joseph Klimas, Vice President of Portfolio Research & Consulting Group at Natixis; Franklin Tsung, President of Appcrown; Christopher L. Davis, President of Money Management Institute and Steven W. Stone, Partner at Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP. More information can be found at www.uapstandards.org.
###

About The Spaulding Group, Inc.

With offices in the New York City and Los Angeles metropolitan areas, The Spaulding Group, Inc. is the leader in investment performance measurement products and services. TSG provides consulting along with GIPS and non-GIPS verification services; offers a unique Software Certification service; publishes The Journal of Performance Measurement®, a quarterly publication launched in 1996; and hosts the Performance Measurement Forum. The firm also sponsors the annual Performance Measurement, Attribution and Risk (PMAR) conference and PMAR Europe, which have come to be recognized as the leading performance measurement conferences in the industry. TSG’s Institute of Performance Measurement offers performance measurement training, including a fundamental’s course on performance measurement, a course on performance attribution, and two CIPM exam preparation courses.

About BrightScope

BrightScope is a financial information company that brings transparency to opaque markets through independent research and analysis. Delivered through web-based software, BrightScope data drives better decision-making for individual investors, corporate plan sponsors, asset managers, broker-dealers, and financial advisors. The BrightScope Rating™, developed in partnership with leading independent 401k fiduciaries, reviews more than 200 unique data inputs per plan and calculates a single numerical score which defines plan quality at the company level. In April 2011, the company launched BrightScope Advisor Pages™, the first comprehensive and publicly available directory of financial advisors designed to help consumers discover information and conduct due diligence on wealth management professionals. BrightScope also markets a suite of data analytics software products to Fortune 1000 companies, asset managers, broker-dealers, financial advisors, and other market participants. Public ratings for more than 46,000 retirement plans as well as rating definitions, criteria and methodologies, and information on more than 575,000 financial advisors and 45,000 advisory firms are available for free at www.brightscope.com.

Monday, May 21, 2012

Clothing & Beta: is there a connection?

The Spaulding Group held its Spring North American Performance Measurement Forum meeting earlier this month in Atlanta, and during the session I had a thought about how the subjects of beta and Jensen's alpha can be related to clothing (being one who is always on the lookout for metaphors and analogies, this seemed to be a good one to share).

Jensen's alpha, as you may recall, is a risk-adjusted measure, that can be viewed as excess return that takes beta into consideration. The typical way we view excess return is:

Jensen's alpha looks a bit like this expression, but with a twist:


First, we're dealing with equity risk premiums (portfolio return minus the risk free rate). But, basic knowledge of algebra would make it clear that if this was the only difference, it would match our excess return. What's really different is the use of beta. Jensen's alpha takes the portfolio's beta and applies it to the benchmark (or more precisely, the benchmark's equity risk premium), essentially saying that THIS is what the portfolio's return WOULD be (net the risk free rate), if beta captured everything for the portfolio; that is, if beta was a perfect predictor of portfolio return. But, Jensen's alpha is usually not zero, based on the portfolio's idiosyncrasies.

And so, where does clothing come in? Well, the benchmark could be looked upon as a school uniform, which everyone is required to wear. Assuming students are required to keep them clean and pressed, there would be no differences. However, if there was some leeway in terms of the shoes a student could wear, whether they could have their uniform custom made, if they could substitute fancy socks, or perhaps (as my friend Steve Campisi likes to do) include a pocket handkerchief, they would be different.

The military doesn't permit much in the way of variation. But, when I was on active duty (with the Field Artillery branch of the U.S. Army) we had the option of substituting "airborne boots" for our standard issue ones; they looked much sharper, and many of us did (even if we weren't airborne!). And, one could buy their "dress blues" off the rack, or get them custom made. And so, even here we had the ability for some degree of idiosyncratic adjustments.

This difference is like what we see with the result from Jensen's alpha. When one speaks of "portable alpha," THIS is the "alpha" they are speaking of: the part of excess return that is completely attributable to the idiosyncrasies of the portfolio, with no baggage from the benchmark.

By the way, you are probably also noticing that we use the term "alpha" here, but in the "Jensen's alpha" context. Whenever anyone simply says "alpha," you should ask "what alpha are you referring to?" This isn't an offensive question, but rather an insightful one, because it reflects your awareness that there are at least two versions of alpha: basic alpha, which is derived from excess return, and Jensen's alpha.