Friday, September 14, 2012

Upcoming Webinars

This coming Monday, September 17, from 11 AM to 1 PM, I will host a webinar titled The 10 Most Common Mistakes GIPS Compliant Firms Make. This webinar is free!

My colleague, John D. Simpson, will host a webinar on Tuesday, September 25, starting at 12 noon (EST). It is a final CIPM Exam Prep event. For two hours John will field questions on both exams. Candidates who took one of John's prep classes, as well as Spaulding Group verification clients and Performance Measurement Forum members can participate at no cost; a nominal fee of only $99 is charged to others.

Please contact Patrick Fowler to register for either or both!

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Performance Measurement Department's Top Five Struggles

We have already heard from a few folks with their lists of the "top five struggles performance measurement departments face," and there's time for more, but soon there won't be!

I posted an invitation last week for readers to submit their lists. One will be selected to win the two most recent books The Spaulding Group has published; all who participate will get a complimentary copy of our very popular Formula Reference Guide. Please email your list to me by this Friday to qualify!

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Remembering 9/11




A new publishing year of The Journal of Performance Measurement will soon be here, along with some new additions

You are probably aware of my habit of referencing anniversaries, especially those ending with a "5" or "0." Well, this Fall will see The Journal of Performance Measurement(R) begin a new publishing year, but it won't end with either of these numbers. However, that doesn't mean we won't be making any significant changes, since two are planned!

First, we are introducing the Performance & Risk Measurement Hall of Fame. And while I would love to take credit for this idea, I must confess that it originated with Journal Advisory Board member Tim Ryan (thanks, Tim!). We thought it was a great one, and are implementing it this coming publishing year. As with the Dietz Award, our Advisory Board will pick the winner (I mean, inductees). Anyone can submit nominations by contacting our editor, Douglas "Tough Mudder" Spaulding. Just get your names in soon (we haven't yet announced the deadline, but will shortly; please email them to Doug). We expect to announce the inductees in the Winter issue (the same issue we announce the Dietz Award winner). Induction will occur annually, with the inaugural class expected to be a bit larger (perhaps 5-10) than future years.

Second, we will publish "Milestone Articles" from time to time. These articles, as the name suggests, are ones that have had a major role in the world of investment performance and risk measurement. We believe they need special attention, and will provide it!

The theme here is obvious (though unintended), is it not? Our profession, though relatively young, has had standard bearers in both people and papers, and our publication (such alliteration!) is providing an opportunity to showcase both.

Have suggestions for the Hall (or milestone articles)? Please let us know!

Friday, September 7, 2012

Trading without the cash

I just got off the phone with a GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) verification client, who is trying to reconcile the settlement and trade date sides of trading.

On trade date, they don't have the cash necessary to make a purchase; but, by settlement date they will have it. From a settlement date perspective, they don't care that the cash isn't there, knowing that by settlement date, the cash will appear. However, from the trade date perspective, we need the cash (or, as Cuba Gooding would put it, "show me the money!").

In performance measurement, I think it's fair to say that we don't care about settlement. Of course, in our hearts we do, but not in our returns.

In order to pull this off, we need to create cash on trade date. Ideally, we post a fictitious transaction that brings the necessary cash in for the trade, which will be picked up by our return formula (e.g., Modified Dietz). When the cash finally arrives, we need an offsetting cash transaction, so that the two cancel out. We can call the trade date event a "pseudo cash" transaction, or an "anticipated cash" position, or whatever you wish, but something is needed.

Thoughts?

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Time for a brief survey

Our firm's COO, Patrick Fowler, recently asked us to answer this question:

What are the top five struggles performance departments face?

Before sharing with you our responses, I thought I'd ask YOU to respond. And to encourage you to do so, we'll offer a prize: all who respond within the next week will have the opportunity to win a copy of our latest two books: The Handbook of Investment Performance and The Spaulding Group's Guide to the Investment Performance Standards. And everyone who responds will get a copy of our very popular Formula Reference Guide.

Simply email your response to me at DSpaulding@SpauldingGrp.com, and include your address. I will announce the winner and list all the "struggles" offered, as well as those that we came up with, in about two weeks.

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

To rebalance or not to rebalance your benchmark

I was recently interviewed by Money magazine on the subject of benchmark rebalancing. Let's say your strategy is 70% equities and 30% bonds, and you are using the S&P 500 for the equity component and the Barclay's Agg for bonds. At some point, because market conditions have shifted, you underweight stocks, overweight bonds, and put some of your money into cash, so that your portfolio is now 40% stocks, 50% bonds, and 10% cash. Do you (a) introduce a cash index into the mix and (b) rebalance?

This is the difference between tactics and strategy. If your long term strategy is 70% equities and 30% bonds, and this tactical move is temporary (however we define "temporary"), I'd say that you leave the benchmark as it is. The main reason is that THIS is your strategy and you want to be able to determine if the tactical move was a good one or not. If you changed the makeup of the benchmark and rebalanced, it would be more difficult to assess whether or not the shift was a good one.

Here's another example: you're entirely in stocks but have decided to avoid the financial sector for the next few months: should your index reflect this shift?

The answer: No! If you make the index ex financials, then you won't know if this tactical move was a good one or not.

I recall a few years ago, Frank Sortino spoke of a manager who invested in Japan and who had superior performance, but had a high tracking error. The reason for the high tracking error: he avoided Japanese banks, thus the makeup of the portfolio was significantly different enough from the benchmark to produce this large tracking error. A prospective client liked the performance but not the tracking error. The manager's reply: well, we could invest in some bad banks if you'd like. Wrong answer! The right one would have been to rerun the tracking error against the index, ex financials, to demonstrate how the investor did against the index with the same mix; but this would only be to mollify the prospective client's concerns about the high tracking error, and to clearly demonstrate its source. He could go further and provide attribution that would highlight where the outperformance came from. But the index, for comparison purposes, should remain with financials.

Tactics vs. strategy: it's important to keep these points in mind when considering changes to the benchmark.