Tuesday, July 10, 2012

The Spaulding Group now offers Opeational Reviews

The Spaulding Group announced yesterday that we now offer operational reviews. While we've actually been performing this service for 20 years, we never told anyone about it...seems odd, right? When a client would come to us and ask, "can you review our operation, to identify opportunities, problems, issues, etc.?" we would reply "yes, we can!" Well, we decided we should "go public" with this service, and make it formal. The text of the release:

The Spaulding Group, Inc. (TSG) announced today that it is formalizing a performance and risk operational review. The service is a thorough, comprehensive and detailed analysis of a firm's performance and risk measurement operations.   TSG's Operational Review Service provides the firm with a validation of what they're doing right, as well as ideas to enhance their organization and the services they provide to both their internal and external clients.

"Over the past 20 years we have conducted operations reviews for several asset managers and plan sponsors. We are excited to announce the formalization of this service," said TSG's president, David Spaulding, CIPM. The review covers the organization's structure, calculations, functionality, reporting, systems, workflow, completeness, and controls. Upon completion, clients will be provided with a comprehensive assessment of how they are doing, as well as how and where they can improve.

The service is available to any firm or institution with a performance measurement function, whether it's a separate department or an "extra duty" for one or more members of the team. This includes asset managers, pension funds, endowments, foundations, government agencies, and custodians. There is no defined way for an organization to be structured or staffed; there are many variables which can influence the choices firms make.This service will provide firms with an assessment of how they can improve their operations and ultimately benefit the overall investment process.

To learn more, please email or call (732-873-5700)  
Chris Spaulding.

Monday, July 9, 2012

UAPS Moving Forward

The Universal Advisor Performance Standards' Advisory Board held its first meeting at the end of June. And while much of the session was devoted to becoming acquainted and discussing the group's role, preliminary comments were made regarding the draft white paper, which can be found at the official UAPS website.

Two weekends ago saw yet more commentary in the press, this time in the Jason Zweig's "Intelligent Investor" column in The Wall Street Journal. Several other publications have also referenced these new standards, including USA Today and Forbes.

If you haven't yet read the white paper, please do. And if you'd like to share your thoughts, please feel free to drop me an email.

We are excited by the attention UAPS has received. Our advisory board consists of an impressive group of individuals, from a cross section of industry segments, who all agree that these standards are needed. We will strive to keep the public informed of our progress.

Sunday, July 8, 2012

What we might learn from the Higgs boson?

I must confess a fair amount of interest in the recent discovery of the Higgs boson, aka "The God Particle." It is an amazing story, though its true meaning seems beyond the grasp of most of us mortals. I won't bother to attempt to explain what it is, since there are many resources available on the web, but briefly, as I understand it, it is the thing which causes the protons, neutrons, etc. to, in a word, coagulate into matter; otherwise they would be merely energy. I am confident my friend Jose Menchero, whose doctorate is in theoretical physics, could do a great job explaining it. Hopefully, he won't critique this post.

In this weekend's WSJ, Michio Kaku, a CUNY theoretical physics professor, wrote (in "The Spark That Caused the Big Bang") about the facility in Europe where the discovery was made (Kaku described it as a donut shaped structure with a circumference of 27 miles, which borders Switzerland and France).

He tells of how two proton beams are shot through the structure, in opposite directions, and accelerated to near light speeds. They are forced to collide, and "for a fraction of a trillionth of a second, the Higgs boson appears."

We often speak of precision in performance measurement. I would think a trillionth of a second would be quite a fraction; the amount of time spoken of here perhaps doesn't have a word associated with it, it's so small, or if there is a word, we aren't familiar with it, so it was left out of the article.

Apparently the expression "God particle" hasn't always been embraced by physicists, and I recall reading this past week that some refer to it as the "goddamn particle," because of its refusal to be found. But found it has been; at least the confidence level of those who claim it is at the "99.9999%" level, which seems pretty darn confident.

In performance and risk measurement we deal with numbers all the time. And we strive to be as confident as possible with the accuracy of what we produce. Fortunately, our returns are typically shown to only two decimal places (i.e., to basis points), though some like to show fractions of these (and I admit that I do, too, when the numbers are so tiny that they'd be 0.00% otherwise), while others prefer to just show the return to a single decimal place.

And so, what might we learn from the Higgs boson? That some things can be illusive; if we want to discover them, we must be patient and persevere. That perhaps we need to think of some of our industry's own "Higgs bosons." That is, are there things we merely take for granted, without any empirical evidence? I believe there are; in fact, I'm attempting to address two of them right now. We are blessed with some true researchers, such as Jose, who, perhaps because of their educational pursuits, are quite adept at the rigors of research. We can probably stand a few more. Our industry, unlike physics, is still very much at its infancy. New discoveries and ideas arise on a regular basis; perhaps this is one reason so many of us enjoy it.

Friday, July 6, 2012

A twist on handling the interaction effect

One of the topics which often results in debate is the interaction effect. Recall that in performance attribution, specifically with the "Brinson models," we have two effects: allocation and selection. Depending on how we calculate these effects we may have a third: interaction. The formula for interaction is:

I.e., the difference in returns (portfolio minus benchmark), which reflecdts the selection decision, and the difference in weights (portfolio minus benchmark), which reflects allocation.

There are some who argue that the interaction effect should never be shown individually; that since no one is making an "interaction decision," it has no value and is unworthy of any attention. That the interaction effect properly belongs with selection: end of story!

On the other hand, there are folks like me who see value in the interaction effect and believe that the allocation effect should not be influenced by the selection decision (by using the portfolio's returns rather than the benchmark's in the formula), and likewise the selection effect shouldn't be influenced by allocation decision (by using the portfolio's weight rather than the benchmark's). As a result we're left with the interaction effect.

I, and one of my esteemed and well regarded colleagues, recently got a note from someone from a software vendor on this topic:

We have customer who wants to split a reporting period into two sub-periods. In the first sub-period they want the Interaction Effect added to the Stock Selection Effect, but in the second they want the Interaction Effect added to the Asset Allocation Effect.

Is there any reason why this may not be valid?

My colleague responded that interaction should only be included with selection, and that this approach is invalid. I strongly disagreed. If the selection decision is a good (i.e., the portfolio return is higher than the benchmark's) but the allocation decision was a poor one (where the portfolio weight is less than the benchmark weight), the interaction effect will be negative: why should the selection effect get this baggage? Why should it be lowered because of a poor allocation decision?

While I prefer to see the interaction effect analyzed to determine where it is to be placed (if it isn't going to appear separately), the approach this fellow's client wants is apparently an attempt to spread the effect across the other two, rather than arbitrarily always placing it with one or the other. Granted this method is one that employs an arbitrary assignment of the effect, but is done so in a manner that is consistent, just as always putting it with interaction is consistent. One cannot "game" this approach, so as to always optimize one effect rather than another.

To me, this is equivalent to always placing it with one or the other effects; it's just that it's alternating back-and-forth. I see nothing wrong with this approach.

Do you? Have some thoughts? Please share them below!

Thursday, July 5, 2012

First Principles in Performance & Risk

A first principle is refers to "any axiom, law, or abstraction assumed and regarded as representing the highest possible degree of generalization."

Fields such as philosophy, mathematics, and physics have them.

Does performance and/or risk measurement? I think there are candidates. For example, that time-weighted returns eliminate or reduce the impact of cash flows. Also, that money-weighted returns include the impact of cash flows.

What else? Should we, as an industry, have agreed upon first principles? I think we should. What do you think?

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

A mid-week holiday

It has become fashionable here in the United States to move holidays to a Monday or Friday, so as to have a three-day weekend. This has happened with Memorial Day and Veterans' Day, for example.

I was born on Veterans' Day (what used to be Armistice Day), and I always liked getting my birthday off. But several years ago they (whoever "they" are) decided to make it forever a Friday, and so it's rarely where it's supposed to be (my birthday).

A few holidays have escaped this trend. January 1 would be difficult to do this to. And fortunately Christmas remains December 25, but there's still the potential for those "inside the beltway" to decide it should always be the fourth Friday in December (after all, Martin Luther King's, Abe Lincoln's, and George Washington's have all been moved, why not Jesus Christ's? But let's hope not.).

July 4th is yet another that most likely won't move. I suppose it would be difficult to celebrate July 4th on July 6th, though by simply calling it "Independence Day" it could happen.

But to have a holiday smack in the middle of the week is a bit awkward. Many have taken the past two days off, so as to have five consecutive days away from the office, and many no doubt are taking the next two off (for the same reason). And a few (like our firm's COO, Patrick Fowler) took the two before and two after, to make it a full week off and only use four vacation days.

Yesterday I commented about July 4th on Facebook; I'll share some of what I wrote:

Tomorrow is a day of celebration here in these United States. But like Memorial Day, many don't fully grasp its meaning: it's the day we declared our independence from England, and what led to the many years of battle for us to actually become an independent nation.

Those brave men who signed this document were, in essence, signing their death penalties, for if we had lost the war, they surely would have been put to death.

Today we cannot be involved in a war but a few years before we hear the chorus of those who want us to depart; where's the fortitude? But during the long battle for independence, we persevered.

Let us give thanks to those who took those bold steps so that we could have the freedoms we so cherish today. Happy July 4th! And God Bless America!

July 4th is a special day in our nation's history, and I wish my fellow Americans a "Happy July 4th!" It's a special day for me personally, because it's the day I met my wife of nearly 40 years. And so we have an extra reason to celebrate!

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Misleading information is legal?

While a great deal of attention was paid to the U.S. Supreme Court's decision on Obamacare this past week, another ruling should garner some interest, too: their conclusion that the 2006 Stolen Valor Act infringes on speech protected by the First Amendment. This means that individuals can falsely claim they won military decorations. As you might imagine, lots of folks are quite upset by this.

We encounter misrepresentations often, do we not? I recall getting a resume from someone once who claimed he was a Harvard graduate. After hiring him we learned (through a background check) that while he did manage to spend one semester at Harvard, he neither graduated from Harvard nor had a degree whatsoever; he was terminated as this was merely one of the fabrications in his resume.

Some folks use job titles which they actually do not have; they apparently like them better than their real ones. I knew a salesman who had "vice president" on his business card, even though he wasn't a VP; his justification was that it helped him sell. On the other hand, my Uncle Joe (everyone has one, right?) was a safe deposit vault attendant for First Pennsylvania Bank, and he would sometimes say he was "vice president of mops and brooms." Granted, it was clear that he was kidding; some folks aren't in their use of incorrect titles.

The greatest example of misrepresentation is clearly Bernie Madoff; at least in recent memory. Sadly, he managed to fool a lot of people for a very long time.

Rules such as the UAPS (Universal Advisor Performance Standards and GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) exist so that individuals can provide performance information in a way that doesn't misrepresent. As Mike Alfred of Brightscope (who is working with The Spaulding Group on the UAPS) stated in an interview with WSJ's Jason Zweig, "Any industry that achieves high credibility across society has consistent standards for reporting outcomes so that a third party can judge whether you're doing a good job or not." Misrepresentation, regardless of whether it is protected by the free speech amendment, has long been found to be unwanted.